top of page
Writer's pictureTravis Brown

FilmQuest 24: "Hunting Matthew Nichols" - movie review

Updated: Nov 6



A gripping faux-documentary thriller, Hunting Matthew Nichols explores obsession and mystery in the search for truth.
A haunting search for truth unfolds in Hunting Matthew Nichols, where obsession and mystery collide in a gripping faux-documentary thriller.

Young men can be obsessed to the point of losing themselves, often isolated and disconnected. We’ve all heard the jokes about guys living in their moms’ basements, shut-ins with interests that remain hidden. Is it just gaming, or something darker? These anxieties were rampant during the “Satanic Panic,” but today, we find new idols and obsessions. In horror, The Blair Witch Project became one such phenomenon, inspiring countless would-be filmmakers who saw the dream of creating a classic with just a camcorder. This spirit lives on today, where any film can inspire others to chase their vision.


But what happens when the pursuit of a dream spirals into a nightmare? Hunting Matthew Nichols, a compelling docudrama thriller by Markian Tarasiuk, follows a young woman searching for answers 23 years after her brother’s disappearance. Like similar faux-documentaries, new discoveries resurface old wounds with devastating impact. The standout performances by Tara Nichols and filmmaker Tarasiuk add a human touch that keeps the suspense engaging.


Lately, docudramas have been flooding the market, but Hunting rises above, skillfully blending found footage, narrative, and interviews. The setup appeals to true crime enthusiasts within the horror community, making it a strong entry in the genre. Though the deeper dive into Matthew’s story dulled some of the initial intrigue, perhaps due to the overwhelming volume of films I watch weekly, Hunting Matthew Nichols still offers a fresh, well-paced take. Even if the hunt itself doesn’t fully grip you, this film outshines many overdone documentaries on streaming platforms. It’s a promising addition to a genre currently gaining serious momentum.


3/5


Hunting Matthew Nichols

Directed By: Markian Tarasiuk

Produced By: Markian Tarasiuk, Sean Harris Oliver, Amy Laurel Barager

Lead Producers: Lucy McNulty, Matt Villeneuve

Cinematography: Justin Sebastian

24 views0 comments

Commenti


bottom of page